How we test
The test keeps the cutting method and the pass mark the same, on our standard wood, A-grade FAS spruce. We change two things on purpose: the steel and the micro-bevel angle.
1. Thin the edge
Behind the brand's grind, we sharpen a secondary bevel. It thins the blade before the final edge goes on.
We generally recommend 11° per side. The tests on record used secondary bevels from 9° to 20° per side.
2. Set the micro-bevel
A small final bevel right at the very edge. Its angle is the number we track. A lower angle cuts better but is more fragile.
3. Push-cut the wood
The edge is pressed straight down through A-grade FAS spruce, without sliding. Spruce is our standard wood, so results can be compared, and each test lists the wood it used.
4. 600 cuts to pass
If the edge lasts 600 cuts, it passes and we stop counting. If it fails sooner, we record the cut where it failed.
The number we report: the best passing angle
For each steel and each brand, we report the best passing angle: the smallest micro-bevel angle that still passed 600 cuts. A lower angle cuts better but holds up less, so this is the thinnest edge that steel held in our tests.
Some steels have many tests, some have one. Each steel's page shows how many tests sit behind its number, and says so plainly when that number rests on one or two passing tests.
Two more things that change the result
We change the steel and the angle on purpose. Two other things also change how long an edge lasts: how the brand heat treated the steel, and heat damage left in the edge by earlier grinding.
Heat treat by brand
Heat treat is how a brand heats and hardens the steel, and it differs by brand. So the same steel at the same angle can pass 600 cuts from one brand and fail early from another. That is why we split every steel by brand instead of pooling the results.
Heat damage in the edge
Grinding can leave a heat-damaged layer in the steel near the very edge. An edge sharpened into that layer can fail early. It often takes a second or third sharpening to remove it, and only then does the edge hold a thinner micro-bevel. We show these results for context. A failure caused by heat damage is not counted against the steel's best passing angle.
Glossary
- Micro-bevel
- A small final bevel right at the very edge of the blade. Its angle is the number we measure. A lower angle makes a thinner edge that cuts better but is more fragile.
- Secondary bevel
- The bevel we sharpen behind the brand's grind, to thin the blade before the micro-bevel goes on. We generally recommend 11° per side; the tests on record used 9° to 20°.
- Degrees per side
- The angle between one face of the edge and a line down the middle of the blade. Every angle on this site is per side.
- Push cut
- The edge is pressed straight down through the wood without sliding.
- A-grade FAS spruce
- The wood we test on. FAS stands for “Firsts and Seconds”, the top grade of lumber: mostly clear boards without knots. It is formally a hardwood grade, but spruce sellers use it too.
- HRC
- Hardness on the Rockwell C scale; higher means harder steel.
- Best passing angle
- The smallest micro-bevel angle that passed 600 cuts. A steel's best passing angle is the lowest any brand reached; each brand also has its own.
- Heat treat
- How a brand heats and hardens the steel. It differs by brand, so the same steel can give different results from different brands.
- Other
- A known steel that fits none of the families above.